Me too. The second one sounds very homemade. I just like it for her vocals particularly at that one part. It could be cleaned up though.
mark i was just thinking about posting that song. i personally think the version done by Jeff Buckley is probably the best though. its really to bad he had to die so young :( i also like the version done by bon jovie with piano and violin.

Oh, I so Love Jeff Buckley's Hallelujah, I still get chills listening to this song. I remember purchasing this album "Grace" when it was released some years ago, it moved me greatly. His voice is very beautiful.

I was looking to post this myself, but it appears I was beat to the punch. I'm glad to see others appreciate the beauty. The song brings me joy but I feel as if I want cry (I think I may have in the past) when listening to this moving rendition.