Excellent work Paul. I can see that you put a lot of effort into your post.
However, I for one can not accept the premise of fallen angels all of a sudden becoming human enough to carry out the sexual act.
Angels, whether fallen or not, and I am happy to concede they can appear in human form, are spirit beings. They have no bodies. Most of the time we all remember this, though here some seem to forget. Because angels are spirit beings they are not equipped to consummate a marriage and to sire offspring. Demons can do all sorts of shocking and even frightening things. This, however, is not one of them. They can’t bring forth giants because they simply can’t bring forth.
Now, everyone is welcome to disagree with the ole Major and we will still be friends, and I will not argue the point, but it seems to me that we as humans have this inbred problem with "Romance". By that I mean IMO, it seems that man, because of his romantically way of looking at reality at times, tends to come up with things that sound really good but overlook the simple explanation. What sells seems to replace what is mundane when the mundane is simple and easy. That is why we add sex to all of the advertisements we sell to sell our products. SEX sells. CONSPERIECY sells.
Now I, and the others who believe that all of this in Genesis 6 about "sons of God" and "daughters of men" are simply the intermarrying of two lines of human beings is admittedly tame to that of demons, and fallen angels having sex with women and then these "giants" walking the earth. Good stuff for books that is for sure.
But it has been said before and I do not remember who or when but.........
"Sometimes the best answer is the simple one that makes the most sense."
When we read and consider the whole context in the previous chapters of Genesis, we are given a glimpse of two competing lines, the godly line of Seth and the wicked line of Cain, human beings. Now we may choose to ignore it, but it non the less is there for us to see. No where do we see any conversation in previous chapters about fallen angels in the context leading up to chapter 6.
Having established the plan in the garden, after affirming that there would be a constant struggle between the seed of the woman and the seed of the serpent we see pictures of each of these armies. We see Seth’s line about the business of exercising dominion, in submission to the Lord. We see Cain’s line dishonoring the law of God and making names for themselves.
But the future is not mere co-existence between the two lines. The story builds toward the great crisis of Noah’s flood that we see in Genesis chapter 6. The great change, what creates the great downward spiral of humanity on the earth is that the two lines come together as one. That is, the godly line of Seth, the sons of God, seeing how attractive are the daughters of men, the wicked line of Cain, decide to take them as wives.
The end result, however, isn’t mere dilution. It’s not that the now joined line becomes morally lukewarm, but that evil spreads, grows, deepens. Chuck Swindoll reminds us, if you drop a white glove in the mud, the mud doesn’t get all glovey and white.
But now we are the sons of God (no longer sons and daughters of Adam...the first Adam)...hence forth after being born from above, we are "spirit beings" in this world but not of it...we are spirit beings temporarily dwelling in these tents, which are wearing out (in my case more swiftly lately as I am getting closer to going home)...spirit beings in flesh bodies that can procreate...Hmmm...who woulda'thought?
It's all good...I can defend your position as well. As I said, bottom line is I will not be dogmatic on this point, but it is odd that no one held this view in the church for nearly 300 years. Whether when I know even as I am known it turns out to be theory 1, 2, or 3 it matters not, but it is interesting to explore and discuss all the possibilities. After all the majority of presentations on this tradition are apocryphal in nature and Jesus Himself apparently never taught about it, as far as we know, but their is a long and unending history of those holding the "angels" manifest view.
In His love
brother Paul