When I became a Christian I brought with me my old earth age beliefs but I soon had them challenged. For example what do you think Jesus meant when He said:
John 10:35
“The Scriptures cannot be discredited”.
I take this to mean that Jesus believed in the entirety of the Old Testament and what do you believe Jesus meant when He said:
Matthew 19:4
"Haven't you read," he replied, "that at the beginning the Creator 'made them male and female,'
I take this to mean that Jesus believed that the beginning of time was marked by the creation of the first people and what do you think God meant when He said:
Genesis 1:5
God called the light “day,” and the darkness he called “night.” And there was evening, and there was morning—the first day.
I take this to mean that the original Hebrew meaning for 'evening' and 'morning', which can only be interpreted as being a description of a 24 hour period and no longer, means that the first six days were all 24 hour periods and that this really was the first week at the beginning of time.
There are masses of evidence to support a young Earth but scripture can't be discredited, and remember God can do anything. What do you think?
You asked, What do I think of John 10:35.......
"If he called them gods, unto whom the Word of God came, and the Scriptures cannot be broken".
I do not think that the verse is speaking to an 'Old or New " earth paradigm. Correct Bible understanding always hinges on "Context". The context is that Jesus is saying that "IF" princes and magistrates, appointed and anointed and receiving this honor by grace, were not at fault when they called themselves gods. or when they were referred to as gods, then how could HE, Jesus, the only begotten SON of God deserve to be stoned because He rightfully declared Himself to be God in a body of flesh.
Then Genesis 1:5 says........
"God called the light “day,” and the darkness he called “night.” And there was evening, and there was morning—the first day."
The Hebrew word for “day” and the context in which it appears in Genesis will lead to the conclusion that “day” means a literal, 24-hour period of time.
However, The Hebrew word yom translated into the English “day” can mean more than one thing.
It can refer to the 24-hour period of time that it takes for the earth to rotate on its axis.
It can refer to the period of daylight between dawn and dusk.
And it can refer to an unspecified period of time (e.g., “back in my grandfather’s day . . .”).
It is used to refer to a 24-hour period in Genesis 7:11. It is used to refer to the period of daylight between dawn and dusk in Genesis 1:16. And it is used to refer to an unspecified period of time in Genesis 2:4.
So, the real question comes down to what does yom mean in Genesis 1:5–2:2 when used in conjunction with ordinal numbers.
Are these 24-hour periods or something else? Could yom as it is used here mean an unspecified period of time? I am no expert and have no answer for you.
Now for Matthew 19:4...............
"Haven't you read," he replied, "that at the beginning the Creator 'made them male and female,'
Personally I do not think that Jesus was speaking to the beginning of time was marked by the creation of the first people by referencing them as male and female. IMO He was simply going back to God's original plan of marriage One man for One woman. God created one of each for each other setting the example for all man and women forever.
To say that Jesus was speaking to and old or new earth is reading into the Scriptures what we want them to say instead of accepting them for what they actually do say.
Now please do not misunderstand me because I do not know. In fact IMO no one knows.
But, according to those who believe in Young Earth Creationistion, dinosaurs lived alongside humans 6,000 years ago, before the great flood described in Genesis 6-9. That means they would have to have been included in the Ark. Some Christians dispute the existence of dinosaurs all together, claiming that bones excavated by scientists are a ruse meant to cause confusion among believers. The problem comes up in that there has not been any fossil record of humans found with those of the dinosaurs.
If man and dinosaurs co-existed during the 6000 year record, would it not then demand that the bones of each one be found together?
Now consider Genesis 1:2....
"And the earth was without form, and void, and darkness was upon the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters".
Before the creative process begins in verse 3, there is "water" on the earth. Where did the water come from.