And please! If you don't want to answer, don't!!
Calling out
@Great Fiction
...and more!!!!
I am quite fond of ethics, and one of it's greatest contributers is Frédéric Bastiat - 1801-1850
quote: - “Government is the
great fiction, through which everybody endeavors to live at the expense of everybody else.”
Frédéric Bastiat
Because Bastiat often wrote sophisms and satire with extreme eloquence, it is in the spirit of his philosophical sarcasm that I use the name “Great Fiction.” For I am moved also to reject the “Great Fiction ethically”, yet will admonish just and ethical law in contrast.
In France Bastiat fictitiously wrote a petition in behalf of the candlestick-makers to parliament urging them to support the making of new laws that would force all people in society to block off the competing sunlight that was harming the candlestick business. He urged parliament to prohibit any sunlight to enter into peoples homes; this would mean that windows should be lawfully shuttered, and any opening to the house should be lawfully closed off to benefit candlestick production (this of course was philosophical wit to disclose absurdity).
The satire persisted that a powerful competitor had come to the France to ruin the economy with low prices and the candlestick business along with others would soon be in ruin. The culprit being the sun which would shine down in great quantity must be dealt with using the law. For this was entirely unfair, for the sun was flooding the market with too much light, and in order to properly support the candlestick making business something had to be done! It was then critical to lawfully force everyone in the dark to support the candlestick business.
This of course moves to absurdity and his real point was that to use the law to crush some business in order to protect other business is also an absurdity; yet can it be that his real point if you read him to entirety is that it is immoral for anyone to use the law to intervene arbitrarily?
Bastiat is also considered by many to be the precursor of the Austrian School of Economics, which is the only “ethical” economic school in existence by rigid standards in Natural Rights Theory.
You can enjoy reading the petition here
http://bastiat.org/en/petition.html
However the reference to "Great Fiction" is in his sophism of "Government" which is also an enjoyable read.
http://bastiat.org/en/government.html