There's 2 things in particular I like about my church. First and foremost, EVERYTHING is centered around the Gospel. My toes are stepped on at least once every sermon, which is essential to growing in Christ. If I'm not made uncomfortable during a service, I wonder why I'm there to begin with. I want to be challenged, refined, and taught what I can do to serve God better. If the messages are easy to digest and don't require any self-examination, go somewhere else.
Second, my church is full of different people. Young, old, white, black, rich, poor, and we all love each other. We're very casual in our dress, contemporary in our worship, but serious about the Word. We rarely have disagreements and when we do, they're minor and always sorted out. Our congregation has 125 members, so we're not big by any means, but have almost doubled in the past year.
In my experience, our pastor's unashamed willingness to preach God's word, no matter how difficult it is to hear, fills our hearts so much more than the fluffy stuff you hear at so many churches today. Amazingly, our pastor is only 24 years old! I was on our Leadership Team when we called Him unanimously. We were all nervous, but all convinced beyond a shadow of a doubt that he was called...God is at work!
My only complaint, and this is true everywhere, is that sometimes too few people do too much of the work. I would say that we're better about this than most, but if 3 or 4 people run every ministry, volunteer for everything, and always seem to be running the show, we run the risk of "our" church becoming the church of those individuals. Not maliciously, but by default.