I'm lost. Can you clarify?
If you are saying I'm deflecting, I would like a clear explanation as to how since I am a very straightforward person. Perhaps my writing is coming across wrong and I need to address it.
The point of my post is that there are questions that atheists and new believers, myself including, have had or do have or that didn't have but came up from others asking those particular questions. I don't find anything wrong with inuring, God wants us to get to know him, correct? If so, that means everything about him, which can mean the difficult things as well, no?
Hope I'm not completely misinterpreting your post, Rumely....
I'm saying that an atheist is deflecting when he brings up that question, not that you were deflecting. You are right in that this question is brought up by atheists as an objection to faith. Certainly it is good to know as much as possible about God, but the trouble is that there is no simple, direct statement in Scripture about the fate of the mentally ill, mentally handicapped, or children. We look at a number of verses and make educated guesses, if you will, on that subject. But, even if there were a verse that said that children under a certain age, for instance, were automatically taken into Heaven, it would be irrelevant. The atheist is not a child or mentally incapacitated. The mere fact that he identifies as an atheist means he has the capability and therefore the responsibility for moral and spiritual decisions, so God's treatment of those who are children or incapacitated has nothing to do with him or what he should do.
Does that clarify my post better? I am not trying to discourage any inquiry into the question, in fact, I will be interested in seeing KingJ's response. Thinking on it, you and I are probably envisioning somewhat different scenarios in which this question may come up, which may be contributing to the confusion.